7 minute read

Political Protest

Comic Strip And Graphic Novel



After a long period of sociopolitical quiescence—born of newspapers' fears of offending subscribers and advertisers—the comic strip resumed some of its original satiric purpose, which it had shown in the nineteenth century. Walt Kelly's Pogo in its innocent-looking, Disneyish, animal-fabulous garb, indicted Senator Joseph McCarthy in the early 1950s. The traditional taboo of the "controversial" was finally broken with Jules Feiffer, whose work was nevertheless confined to the progressive weekly magazine, unlike Garry Trudeau's syndicated Doonesbury (commencing in 1970, in the early 2000s the strip appears in four hundred newspapers worldwide). Highly topical and scathing of government lies and deceptions (the Watergate scandal was for Trudeau what McCarthy was for Kelly), and sympathetic to new social movements such as feminism, Trudeau has been called the most influential (and is probably the most regularly censored) cartoonist in the world; he won a Pulitzer Prize for cartooning in 1975. The drawing is stiff, but the dialogue perfectly tuned. His nearest British equivalent is Steve Bell, a principled, caustic, socialist critic of capitalist antics, whose daily "If" has appeared in the Guardian newspaper since 1981. His crude, chaotic linear style and composition derive from his background in children's comics. The child-like style, verging on bizarre abstractions, is best exemplified in the poster work of Berkeley artist Doug Minkler.



All kinds of long-established taboos, mainly in the social and sexual realm, were broken by the so-called Underground Comics (or comix) starting in the mid 1960s, led by Robert Crumb. These works heralded the sexual revolution that was also visualized by posters, and celebrated illegal drugs and the hippie lifestyle in a manner that is both hilarious and philosophical. Approaching the pornographic, such work endured brushes with law, and for a time it was easier to find these comics in Amsterdam than in their place of origin, the San Francisco Bay area.

The graphic novel emerged in the 1980s from the old comic book, which was typically a collection of short graphic sequences, related to and often reproducing newspaper strips. It has now become a major vehicle of social and political protest, gaining status from Art Spiegelman's autobiographical Holocaust account Maus, which won many prizes and is sold in mainstream bookstores. The genre has lent itself to autobiography laced with radical social critique, as in the feminist advocacy of Marisa Acocella's Just Who the Hell Is SHE Anyway? (1993). The comic strip and comic book format, much used everywhere for educational and didactic purposes, found essentially local critical forms in Latin America: the much-censored Rius (Eduardo del Rio) in Mexico, with his Agachados (The Downtrodden) and Supermachos (The Supermales), cutting a wide swath through the Mexican polis; Roberto Fontanarrosa, with his Boogie el Aceitoso (Boogie [from Humphrey Bogart] the Slippery), a crapulous, sadistic C.I.A. thug and U.S.-hired mercenary, whose laconic wit is his only virtue. Another Argentine, Hector Oesterheld, wrote for artist Alberto Breccia and his son Enrique a tragic life of Che Guevara (Che, 1968), which was burned and suppressed by the government, and Osterheld was "disappeared" (murdered).

An example of socialist political comic, which has remained unique, emerged in Salvadore Allende's Chile (1970–1973), an exciting experiment that was aborted by the military coup of Augusto Pinochet, which banned and burned it. Under the generic title La Firme (Steadfast) the series told amusing Chilean-dialectal and dialectical tales in quintessential Chilean working places and locales, serving to explain the need for the socialist transformation that was then in process and under threat. This was undertaken in tandem with the first radical, and enduring, critique of the Disney comic, which was especially hegemomic in Latin America: How to Read Donald Duck (1971), by Ariel Dorfman and Armand Mattelart, which was translated into a dozen foreign languages (the English edition, 1975, carried the subtitle Imperialist Ideology in the Disney Comic). After Chile's bloody counterrevolution of September 11, 1973, José Palomo, one of the La Firme artists, fled to Mexico where he created a tiny, Wizard-of-Id-like dictator, not at all innocuous like his Brant-Parker prototype, under the title El Cuarto Reich, published in Uno mas Uno. Contemptuous and exploitative of the poverty and sufferings of his people, and backed by U.S.-trained thugs and death squads, he typifies the Third World dictator, especially in U.S.-dominated Latin America. This gag strip, hilarious as well as mordant, was little exported. Yet it is perhaps the only comic strip in the world about the life of truly immiserated majorities, although in the U.S. Aaron McGruder's Boondocks does deal with the impoverished and unemployed black youth, as well as issues of war and peace.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Atelier Populaire. Posters from the Revolution, Paris, May 1968, Texts and Posters. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1969. There is also a collection of ninety-six posters in color published by Dobson in London in 1968. Eighty-seven posters were published in miniature by Usines Université Union, Paris, 1968.

Blum, Paul von. The Art of Social Conscience. New York: Universe Books, 1976. Nineteenth and twentieth centuries.

——. The Critical Vision. A History of Social and Political Art in the U.S. Boston: South End Press, 1982.

Bork, Angela, et al. Die politische Lithographie im Kampf um die Pariser Kommune. Cologne, Germany: Gaehme, Henke, 1976.

Commune de Paris 1871–1971. Exposition du Centenaire. Saint Denis, Musé d'Art et d'Histoire, 1971.

Craven, David. Art and Revolution in Latin America, 1910-1990. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2002. Covers Mexico (1910–1940), Cuba (1959–1989), and Nicaragua (1979–1990).

Cushing, Lincoln. Revolución! Cuban Poster Art. San Francisco: Chronicle Books, 2003. Many OSPAAAL posters.

Davidson, Steef. Images de la révolte 1965–1975. Paris: Musée de l'Affiche et de la Publicité, H. Veyrier, 1982. See introduction.

Diederich, Reiner, and Richard Grübling. Stark für die Freiheit: Die Bundesrepublik in Plakat. Hamburg, Germany: Rasch und Röhring, 1989. With 164 illustrations and commentary on all.

——. "Unter die Schere mit den Geiern." Politische Fotomontage in der Bundesrepublik und Westberlin. Berlin: Elefanten Press Galerie, 1977. Well-documented.

Evans, David, and Sylvia Gohl. Photomontage: A Political Weapon. London: G. Frazer, 1968.

Gaddi, Giuseppe. Fascismo Mai. 100 Manifesti contro la Minaccia fascista in Europa. Milan: La Pietra, 1972.

Grupo Mira . La Grafica del 68, Homenaje al Movimiento Estudiantil. n.p.: Mexico D.F., 1981. Anthology of woodcuts about the repression of 1968.

Heller, Steven. Man Bites Man: Two Decades of Drawings and Cartoons. New York: A and W Publishers, 1981.

Jacobs, Karrie, and Steven Heller. Angry Graphics: Protest Posters of the Reagan/Bush Era. Salt Lake City: Peregrine Smith Books, 1992.

Kunzle, David. Posters of Protest: The Posters of Political Satire in the U.S., 1966–1970. Santa Barbara: University of California, 1971. Exhibition catalog. A shorter version published by New School for Social Research, New York (Triple R. Press), 1971.

——. Murals of Revolutionary Nicaragua, 1979–1992. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995. Includes reproductions of many posters.

Langemeyer, Gerhard, et al. eds. Bild als Waffe: Mittel und Motive der Karikatur in fünf Jahrhunderten. Munich: Prestel-Verlag. 1984. Deals with various media from five centuries, very copiously illustrated.

Lippard, Lucy R. A Different War: Vietnam in Art. Seattle: Real Comet Press, 1990. Works of "high art."

McQuiston, Liz. Graphic Agitation:. Social and Political Graphics since the Sixties. London: Phaidon, 1993. Includes posters from countries around the world seldom regarded in poster history.

Micheli, Mario de. Manifesti Revoluzionari: Europa 1900–1940. Milan: Fratelli Fabbri, 1973. Many Soviet and Soviet-bloc posters.

Philippe, Robert. Political Graphics, Art as a Weapon. Oxford: Phaidon; New York: Abbeville Press, 1982. Comprehensive.

Poster Book Collective of the South African History Archive. Images of Defiance: South African Resistance Posters of the 1980s. Johannesburg: Raven Press, 1991.

Ray, Violet. Advertising the Contradictions. Berkeley, Calif.: V. Ray, 1984. Collaging the real and fantasy worlds.

Rickards, Maurice. Posters of Protest and Revolution. Bath, U.K.: Adams and Dart, 1970. Twenty-one countries represented in a very compact volume.

Shikes, Ralph E. The Indignant Eye: The Artist as Social Critic in Prints and Drawings from the Fifteenth Century to Picasso. Boston: Beacon Press, 1969. Unsurpassed.

Stermer, Dugald, and Susan Sontag. The Art of Revolution: 96 Posters from Cuba. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970. Excellent texts with fine facsimiles.

Thomas, C. David, ed. As Seen by Both Sides: American and Vietnamese Artists Look at the War. Boston: Indochina Arts Project, William Joiner Foundation, 1991.

Track 16 Gallery/Center for the Study of Political Graphics. Decade of Protest, Political Posters from the United States, Vietnam, Cuba 1965–1975. Santa Monica, Calif.: Smart Art Press, 1996.

Wright, Micah. You Back the Attack! We'll Bomb Who We Want! Remixed War Propaganda Posters. New York: Seven Stories Press, 2003. Preface urges readers to break book apart and make enlarged copies into posters.

Yanker, Gary. Prop Art: Over 1000 Contemporary Political Posters New York: Darien House, 1972. Mix of radical, historic, and straight election posters.

David Kunzle

Additional topics

Science EncyclopediaScience & Philosophy: Propagation to Quantum electrodynamics (QED)Political Protest - Cartoon And Caricature In Early Modern Europe, Nineteenth Century, Twentieth Century, Painting, Murals, Photography